Private language argument

Private language is unintelligible

Wittgenstein distinguishes private language from secret codes or idiolects. A secret code can be decoded or taught to others, but a private language, as defined, is unlearnable and untranslatable by anyone else. This distinction underscores the importance of social interaction in language formation and understanding.

Example

Imagine a person invents a language where each word corresponds to a private sensation they experience. No one else can understand or replicate these sensations, making the language unintelligible to others.

Remember this

Understanding the private language argument highlights the social nature of language and the necessity of shared understanding for meaningful communication.

Text adapted from Wikipedia, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Related concepts

Translation

Can we truly understand another language without mistakes?

Concept

Can we ever fully express complex ideas with words?

Chinese room

Chinese Room thought experiment challenges strong AI hypothesis

The Real

How can a word mean different things over time?

Communicative rationality

Communicative rationality aims for mutual understanding, not domination

Deconstruction

Derrida's deconstruction reveals internal contradictions in texts

Swipe through 100 ML concepts daily

Open Pocket Polymath