Can you truly know something if luck plays a role in your belief?
Knowledge
Can you truly know something if luck plays a role in your belief?
Imagine you're at a party and someone claims they met a famous celebrity. You believe them because they seem confident, but later find out it was a coincidence. You thought you knew, but luck influenced your belief.
This scenario shows that just believing something because it feels right doesn't guarantee knowledge. Knowledge requires more than just a lucky guess; there's a deeper connection needed.
Example
You believe you met a celebrity (true belief) because of someone's confident story (luck), not because you have solid evidence (justification).
Remember this
Epistemic luck challenges the idea that true belief alone constitutes knowledge; it highlights the necessity of justification beyond mere confidence.
Text adapted from Wikipedia, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0.
Related concepts
Gettier problem
Can we truly know something if luck plays a role in the truth we believe?
Scientific method
Can luck undermine expert predictions?
Moral responsibility
Moral luck challenges moral responsibility
A priori and a posteriori
Can you know something is true without ever seeing it?
Episteme
Episteme is the Ancient Greek term for 'knowledge' or 'understanding'
Anekantavada
Can one truth fit all perspectives?
Swipe through more Philosophy concepts
Open Pocket Polymath